A recent report by the NGO Project Play asserts that “catastrophic failures” by the UK and French governments have led to the deaths of 22 children attempting to cross the English Channel in the last two years. While the report raises serious concerns, it's crucial to consider the broader context of border security and national sovereignty.

The report focuses on the conditions in northern France, alleging that French police tactics, including teargassing, evictions, and dinghy-slashing, contribute to the dangers faced by migrants. However, these tactics are implemented to deter illegal crossings and maintain order in a challenging environment. The safety of migrants is important, but it must be balanced against the need to control borders and prevent illegal immigration.

The deaths of the 22 children are tragic, and any loss of life is regrettable. However, the report's assertion that these deaths are solely the result of government failures ignores the role played by human smugglers who exploit vulnerable individuals for profit. These criminals are ultimately responsible for placing migrants in dangerous and life-threatening situations.

The UK has provided £473 million to the French government since 2023 for border “securitisation.” While Project Play criticizes the lack of transparency in how these funds are spent, this investment is essential for strengthening border controls and preventing illegal crossings. The UK has a right to protect its borders and control who enters the country.

The report calls for a statutory inquiry and safe routes for asylum seekers. While these proposals may sound compassionate, they risk creating a pull factor that encourages more illegal immigration. Opening up safe routes could overwhelm the asylum system and incentivize people to bypass legal channels.

The report mentions the “one in one out” scheme, claiming that families have been rejected due to documentation issues. While such cases are unfortunate, it's essential to have proper documentation to ensure that individuals are who they claim to be. Border security relies on accurate identification and verification.

The report details alleged instances of teargassing and police brutality. While these allegations should be investigated, it's important to remember that law enforcement officers often face difficult and dangerous situations. They must be able to use appropriate force to maintain order and prevent illegal crossings.

Project Play’s advocacy coordinator, Katie Hall, claims there is a “catastrophic failure” to protect children's rights. However, the primary responsibility for protecting children lies with their parents or guardians. It is irresponsible to place children in such dangerous situations in the first place. The focus should be on preventing illegal crossings and discouraging vulnerable individuals from attempting these perilous journeys.

Ultimately, the report raises valid concerns, but it's crucial to maintain a balanced perspective. Border security is essential for national security and sovereignty. While compassion is important, it must be tempered with realism and a commitment to upholding the law. The UK and France have a right to control their borders and prevent illegal immigration. Any solutions must prioritize these core principles.

The ongoing situation in the English Channel underscores the need for a comprehensive approach to immigration reform that addresses the root causes of migration, strengthens border security, and discourages illegal crossings. The focus should be on preventing vulnerable individuals from being exploited by human smugglers and ensuring that those who seek asylum do so through legal channels.