Rule of Law Prevails: Police Clear Matthew Guy of Moira Deeming’s Unsubstantiated Assault Allegation
With Victoria Police officially finding 'no offence detected,' the Liberal Party can move past internal distractions and focus on the November election.

In a decisive victory for the presumption of innocence and the rule of law, Victoria Police have completely cleared Liberal MP Matthew Guy of assault allegations brought forward by colleague Moira Deeming. The thorough police investigation concluded late Thursday night with a definitive finding of "no offence detected," bringing a swift end to what Guy has rightfully characterized as a set of "ridiculous and unsubstantiated" claims.
The allegations stemmed from a Macedonian community function held on 23 May at a venue on Sommerville Road in Sunshine West. Despite the event being heavily attended and documented—including a friendly social media selfie featuring both MPs and a 26-second CCTV recording of their brief interaction—it took over three weeks for Deeming to lodge a formal complaint with law enforcement on 16 June. The police confirmed that the complainant required absolutely no medical attention, highlighting the lack of any credible physical substance to the complaint.
Following a meticulous review of the available evidence, including CCTV footage and direct engagement with the parties, investigators determined that no laws had been breached. The rapid closure of the file validates Guy’s vehement denials and underscores the danger that unproven allegations pose to individual reputations and institutional stability. Sources close to the public transport spokesperson indicate that he is now actively considering defamation action to legally restore his standing and hold Deeming accountable for the fallout.
Throughout this challenging period, Liberal Leader Jess Wilson demonstrated exemplary and disciplined leadership by refusing to engage in media sensationalism. Wilson correctly insisted on respecting due process, the presumption of innocence, and the privacy of those involved while the police did their job. Her refusal to offer premature commentary prevented the media from turning a private, unfounded dispute into a permanent circus.
With the legal matter now officially resolved, the Victorian Liberal Party is well-positioned to refocus its entire apparatus on the issues that genuinely matter to everyday Victorians. Wilson’s commitment to earning back the trust of families and taxpayers ahead of the crucial November election remains the absolute priority, as evidenced by her scheduled press conference and tour in Mildura.
This outcome serves as a stark reminder of why the foundational principle of the presumption of innocence must always be defended against rushed judgments. When political disputes are escalated to law enforcement without merit, it distracts from the vital work of holding the current government accountable and preparing the state for a fresh legislative start.


